Why should a company care about the price of its shares after the IPO?

The IPO process is essentially this: a private company going public notifies the government that they will be "going public" and (if succesful) they will sell a block of shares in exchange for some amount of money. The company is then listed on a stock exchange (NASDAQ, NYSE, etc.) and the new owners are free to buy/sell those new shares from each other at an agreed upon price.

However, consider this: all the buying and selling of those shares from that point forward is done between the buyer and seller, with no interaction with the original underlying company. For example, when I buy Microsoft stock (MSFT) or sell Google stock (GOOG), neither of those companies see any money from that transaction.

This begs the question...

why does a company care about the price of it's shares after the IPO?

There are multiple reasons, let's explore them:

Shareholder Satisfaction

This is the main reason a company exists. A company with an appreciating share price is increasing the wealth of its shareholders (on paper at least). Consider that shareholders control the board of directors and the board of directors controls the management. A company with an lagging share price over a prolonged length of time would likely face an upset group of shareholders, who could force change on the board of directors and in turn the managers themselves.

Hostile Takeovers

A lofty share price may fend off other companies from attempting a hostile takeover. In order to consider any potential acquisition offer, shareholders will likely only consider offers at or above the current market rate. A lagging share price could leave a company potentially vulnerable to be acquired under less than favorable terms.

Stock Options

Many companies incentive their employees to perform well by granting them stock options, sometimes in lieu of base compensation. Therefore, many of the same people who run the company are also owners of the companies, so it's in their best interest to have an appreciating share price so as to be handsomely rewarded. Similarly, the growing share price will continue to attract talent in the form of other employees.

Additional Share Issuence

A company may find it necessary to go back and issue another round of shares in order to raise capital. This second round will take place after the original IPO and is priced differently. The price of the companies shares on the open market will be a good indicator of how much can be raised during the secondary offering. A company that has neglected it's share price may find it difficult to raise additional capital at the price they want or they may be forced to give away a larger part of the company in order to raise the necessary capital.

Shares = Currency

In most circumstances, the share price of a company is a reflection of expected future earnings. High growth stocks such as Amazon (AMZN) or Netflix (NFLX) trade at large multiples to today's earnings on the basis that shareholders expect the company to perform that well down the road. Companies can take advantage of this mismatch by acquiring other companies and using their inflated share price to pay for the purchase.

Creditworthiness

A declining stock price may make it difficult to secure credit, as creditors want to be assured that the company is financially able to repay the borrowed money, More specifically, it's often indicative of slowing growth, excessive debt or other negative qualities.

The obvious reason for most companies to want a strong stock price is to increase the wealth of their shareholders, but remember that there are multiple other reasons that come into play beyond that. It may become disconnected from reality temporarily, however the share price is a reflection of the perceived financial health of a company and therefore has significant impacts on multiple fronts.

www.investy.com

New Feature: Individual Quote Pages

We've added a great new feature to Investy -- individual quotes for stocks. The best part is you don't even need to be a subscriber to use it!

At the top of the home page you will now see a box to lookup a ticker symbol:

Ss1

All symbols now have a customized page that provides details about the individual stock, mutual fund, or ETF. In the case of mutual funds or ETFs, we provide a complete breakdown of the holdings that comprise that fund. For example, if you search for the symbol AAPL, you get the following analysis of Apple:

Ss2

These individual quote pages are simply the first step in analyzing your portfolio. Subscribers to Investy get all this type of analysis (and much more) spanning their entire portfolio. Sign up for an account today!

www.investy.com

New Features: Bonds, Expense Ratios, More Data

We've added some major new features to Investy that we think you will be excited about.

Support for bonds in asset allocation

Many mutual funds and ETF's include bonds as part of their composition. We've now added support for this when viewing the asset allocation.

Ss1

Minimization of Expense Ratios

This is a huge feature and one that has the potential to save users a tremendous amount of money. Most mutual funds and ETF's charge a fee for investing in their fund, often charged as a percentage of the amount you have invested. This percentage is referred to as the expense ratio. This means that if you have $10,000 invested in a fund with a 2% expense ratio you will be charged $200 annually for the privelage of being invested in this fund.

Investy now includes a new feature that will help to reduce these fees. Any mutual funds or ETF's in your portfolio will be analyzed for their underlying holdings. We will take your funds and find other funds that are a similar match and that have cheaper expense ratios. Needless to say, this is a tremendously powerful tool with which to find alternative investments.

Ss2

Increased Data

We have increased the scope of the investments available to analyze. Thousands of additional mutual funds and ETF's have been added to Investy, along with their underlying holdings. Immediately, this will provide you a more thorough analysis of your portfolio. Further down the road, we have some exciting new features planned that we hope will significantly increase the performance of your portfolio as well as save you money on your existing investments.

www.investy.com

New Features: Market Size, Valuation Analysis, Profitability Analysis

We've made some great changes to Investy and in the process added some awesome features.

Navigation Menu

The main navigation menu has been broken down into categories that will help you understand where each analysis fits in with your portfolio. In the process, the Performance metrics were broken out into individual pages, which makes interpreting them much easier. Company, Sector and Industry performance can now be viewed on their own instead of consolidated.

Ss1

Market Size Breakdown

A new feature was added that shows the breakdown of your investments by market size. This will show you how much allocation you have in Large Cap, Mid Cap and Small Cap stocks.

Ss2
Valuation Analysis (Average and Weighted)

This awesome new feature will show you a valuation analysis across your entire portfolio. Tons of statistics about your portfolio all geared towards valuation. You can view it either by the average across your portfolio or by the weighted calculation according to the weight of each investment in your portfolio.

Ss3

Valuation analysis includes:

  • Sales Per Share
  • Book Value Per Share
  • CFP Per Share
  • FCF Per Share
  • Price to Earnings Ratio
  • Price to Book Ratio
  • Price to Sales Ratio
  • Price to Cash Flow Ratio
  • Price to Free Cash Flow Ratio
  • Dividend Yield
  • Payout Ratio
  • Sustainable Growth Rate
  • Cash Return
  • Forward Earning Yield
  • PEG Ratio
  • PEG Payback
  • Forward Dividend Yield

Profitability Analysis (Average and Weighted)

Similar to how the valuation analysis works, these statistics revolve around the profitability of your portfolio.

Ss4

Profitability analysis includes:

  • Gross Margin
  • Operating Margin
  • EBT Margin
  • Tax Rate
  • Net Margin
  • Sales Per Employee
  • EBIT Margin
  • EBITDA Margin
  • Normalized Net Profit Margin

There are many more features to be added soon, so stay tuned! Let us know if there are any features you'd love to see added to Investy by shooting us an email at suggestions@investy.com

www.investy.com

New Feature: Additional popular portfolios added

Additional popular investors' portfolios have been added to Investy. In addition to the existing portfolios of Warren Buffett, Jim Cramer and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, the following have been added:

George Soros

A Hungarian-American financier, businessman and notable philanthropist. He became known as "the Man Who Broke the Bank of England" after he made a reported $1 billion during the 1992 Black Wednesday UK currency crises. Soros correctly speculated that the British government would have to devalue the pound sterling. In 2010, Forbes lists Soros as the Forbes list of billionaires 35th richest person in the world, and the 14th richest person in America, with a net worth estimated at US$14.2 billion.

T. Boone Pickens

An American financier who chairs the hedge fund BP Capital Management. He was a well-known takeover operator and corporate raider during the 1980s. With an estimated current net worth of about $1.4 billion, he is ranked by Forbes as the 290th-richest person in America and ranked 880th in the world.

Carl Icahn

An American financier, corporate raider, and private equity investor. In 2010 his net worth was US$11 billion, making him the 24th richest American, and as of March 2010 the 59th richest man in the world.

These are fantastic investors, each in their own right and each with a completely different investment style. Enjoy comparing your portfolio to theirs!

www.investy.com

Why use credit when you have cash?

What can be added to the happiness of a man who is in health, out of debt, and has a clear conscience?
-Adam Smith

Although this insightful quote by Mr. Smith should be taken to heart in the wake of the recent financial crisis, in today's modern economy businesses play by a different set of rules.
It is a commonly understood (but often ignored) rule that debt is a crutch for a business, the point proven by the collapse of the banking industry. Nevertheless, many businesses who are financially strong continue to issue debt, which begs the question...why? If a company has the cash and is in a strong financial position, why would it elect to issue debt instead of spending the cash it has?
There are a few reasons:

The first is opportunity cost. That chunk of money they have could be used to get higher returns somewhere else. If they can borrow from a bank at low interest rates to finance their ongoing operations, they can use their cash to get a higher return somewhere else.

The second is credit rating. For public companies, ratings companies give high emphasis to companies with large reserves. This strengthens their ability to pay back the loan should it become necessary. A good credit rating in turn let's the company borrow money at lower rates. When a company can borrow money at low rates, it circles back to the first point where they can now put their reserves to better use.

The third is leverage. Companies can use the cash they have built up to leverage into a larger investment. Assuming the investment works out, it will pay for the cost of borrowing over time. For instance let's say I have $1 million to invest. I can pay all cash for a $1 million apartment building or I can leverage that into a $3 million building. Assuming I run it well, the tenants will pay for the cost of borrowing $2 million and at the end of the term I'll be left with my $3 million building.

For individuals and businesses that have a thorough understanding of it, debt can be a tool to strengthen their economic position and produce superior returns.

www.investy.com

Redesign of Investy Based on Hacker News Feedback

Tonight a redesign of the site was launched based on the fantastic feedback received from the initial launch on Hacker News. To recap, the major issues people brought up with the design were the following:

  • Color scheme needs work, particularly on the green.
  • The plans page was confusing. People didn't understand how the plans were significantly different and the reasoning for the price differences.
  • The frontpage did not make it immediately apparent what the product did.

Let's address them one by one, using screenshot comparisons:

Color scheme needs work, particularly on the green

To address this, the frontpage was redesigned using more natural colors. The emphasis on green was removed and replaced with light colors that emphasized the verbage and content.

Before:

Frontpage-before

After:

Frontpage-after

The plans page was confusing. People didn't understand how the plans were significantly different and the reasoning for the price differences.

This page saw the most significant changes in the redesign as a result of this feedback. In terms of the plans themselves, they were completely simplified:

  • All features are now included with all plans.
  • Pricing was reduced.
  • All plans now include unlimited portfolios, no more varying number of portfolios.
  • The only differentiator in the plans now is the number of stocks available in each portfolio.

The layout was simplified to put focus on the plans themselves rather than the background.

Before:

Pricing-before

After:

Pricing-after

Although it wasn't based on feedback receieved, the decision was made to include the "Why" page in the redesign as well. This page was changed to show examples that actually impacted a user's portfolio. In other words, focus on exactly how the product can make a monetary difference.

Before:

Why-before

After:

Why-after

There are many more changes coming as a result of the feedback received. A planned feature that will be forthcoming is an improvement to data that gets presented in the portfolio. More focus will be put on the question "what do I do next with my portfolio?".

 

Stay tuned.

Retrospective from launching Investy on Hacker News

Timing

This morning I made a post on Hacker News to show the product and gather feedback from the startup community. The feedback was overwhelming and I'm so glad I chose the venue I did. The post was timed for 8AM Eastern in order to capitalize on the morning news browsers. The IRC channel was solicited for feedback as well, which was received immediately.

Basics

Visitors

There was a noticable wave in activity as the post made the front page of HN and the east coast visitors clicked through. The traffic persisted for the next few hours as the central and west coast visitors provided feedback. By about 10AM the post had drifted to the second page and traffic diminished.

Feeback

There was a great mix of both positive and negative feedback. Some of the most constructive feedback was received via the IRC channel. I loved receiving the positive feedback, but the negative comments were the most constructive, so to summarize those, they boiled down to:

  • Color scheme needs work, particularly on the green.
  • The plans page was confusing. People didn't understand how the plans were significantly different and the reasoning for the price differences.
  • The frontpage did not make it immediately apparent what the product did.
  • Go beyond the data. Ultimately, the target audience needs to know what to do with the data, not the data itself.

On a side note, one great thing was the surprising distribution of users recieved from outside the United States. It was great to receieve their feedback, particularly becuase Investy supports stocks listed on international exchanges as well as US exchanges.

Locale

Going Forward

It was reassuring to hear that most of the feedback in terms of feature requests are things that were already on the roadmap. I was somewhat anticipating this but decided that a minimum viable product was the most effective way to validate the future direction of the product.

Some things have been immediately changed:

  • Pricing has been updated based on some great feedback. starpilot pointed out that with the current pricing a potential customer would have to realize a significant return in order to justify the price.
  • The frontpage was updated to reflect the fact that the listed exchanges are data providers, not customers.

Work has already begun on more significant changes to overhaul the Plans page, which will hopefully make it more clear what the differentiations are between the plans -- particulary at a feature set level.

Beyond that, work continues on the next version of the product, which has already begun to incorporate much of the feedback received from the HN community today.

Thanks HN!